Replication Map
Why Replication Matters
Replication is the gold standard of science. This map tracks which findings have been independently tested and what the results show. In psi research, where effects are often subtle and context-dependent, replication chains are critical. They help distinguish between genuine phenomena, statistical flukes, and methodological artifacts.
Chains Tracked
15
Total Attempts
55
Overall Success Rate
31%
(17/55)Replication Map
Tracks all replication relationships documented in the catalog. Organized by paradigm, listing each original study and its replications with outcomes and catalog link status.
Last updated: 2026-03-02
Legend:
- Outcome: Successful / Failed / Mixed / Partial / Anomalous
- Catalog link: explicit = paper has Replicates or Replicated By field pointing to the original; implicit = paper uses extends, critiques, or precursor instead; none = no formal link in Related Studies but title/abstract/notes confirm replication
❌ 1. Precognition — Bem's Feeling the Future
Replication Failed
1. Precognition — Bem's Feeling the Future
Replication Failed
1. Precognition — Bem's Feeling the Future
Original: 📄 bem_2011_feeling — Bem (2011), "Feeling the Future"
galak_2012_correcting_past_meta
❌ 2. Ganzfeld Telepathy
Replication Failed
2. Ganzfeld Telepathy
Replication Failed
⚠️ 3. EEG Correlations — Duane & Behrendt Paradigm
Mixed Results
3. EEG Correlations — Duane & Behrendt Paradigm
Mixed Results
3. EEG Correlations — Duane & Behrendt Paradigm
Original: 📄 duane_1965_extrasensory — Duane & Behrendt (1965), "Extrasensory Electroencephalographic Induction Between Identical Twins"
Second-generation original: 📄 wackermann_2003_correlations — Wackermann et al. (2003)
✅ 4. Double-Slit Consciousness
Replication Successful
4. Double-Slit Consciousness
Replication Successful
4. Double-Slit Consciousness
Original: 📄 radin_2012_consciousness — Radin (2012), "Consciousness and the Double-Slit Interference Pattern"
🔮 5. PEAR REG / Psychokinesis
Mixed Results
5. PEAR REG / Psychokinesis
Mixed Results
5. PEAR REG / Psychokinesis
Original: 📄 jahn_1982_persistent — Jahn (1982), "The Persistent Paradox of Psychic Phenomena"
✅ 6. Presentiment / Electrodermal
Replication Successful
6. Presentiment / Electrodermal
Replication Successful
6. Presentiment / Electrodermal
Original: 📄 radin_2004_electrodermal — Radin (2004), "Electrodermal Presentiments of Future Emotions"
✅ 7. Water Crystal Formation
Replication Successful
7. Water Crystal Formation
Replication Successful
7. Water Crystal Formation
Original: 📄 radin_2006_doubleblind — Radin (2006), "Double-Blind Test of the Effects of Distant Intention on Water Crystal Formation"
✅ 8. Telephone Telepathy
Replication Successful
8. Telephone Telepathy
Replication Successful
8. Telephone Telepathy
Original: 📄 sheldrake_2003_videotaped — Sheldrake & Smart (2003), "Videotaped Experiments on Telephone Telepathy"
Co-original: sheldrake_smart_2003_experimental_tests_telephone — Sheldrake & Smart (2003), "Experimental Tests for Telephone Telepathy"
lobach_bierman_2004_lst_telephone
✅ 9. Animal Telepathy
Replication Successful
9. Animal Telepathy
Replication Successful
9. Animal Telepathy
Original: sheldrake_smart_1998_dog_preliminary — Sheldrake & Smart (1998), "A Dog That Seems to Know When His Owner is Returning"
sheldrake_smart_2000_testing_kane
⚠️ 10. Remote Viewing
Mixed Results
10. Remote Viewing
Mixed Results
10. Remote Viewing
Original: 📄 targ_1974_information — Targ & Puthoff (1974), "Information Transmission Under Conditions of Sensory Shielding"
escola_gascon_2023_cia_remote_viewing
⚠️ 11. Twin Physiological Connectedness
Mixed Results
11. Twin Physiological Connectedness
Mixed Results
11. Twin Physiological Connectedness
Original: 📄 jensen_2012_entangled — Jensen & Parker (2012), "Entangled in the Womb?"
✅ 12. Mediumship — Anomalous Information Reception
Replication Successful
12. Mediumship — Anomalous Information Reception
Replication Successful
12. Mediumship — Anomalous Information Reception
Original: 📄 beischel_2007_anomalous — Beischel & Schwartz (2007), "Anomalous Information Reception by Research Mediums"
⚠️ 13. Remote Staring / DMILS — Experimenter Effects
Mixed Results
13. Remote Staring / DMILS — Experimenter Effects
Mixed Results
13. Remote Staring / DMILS — Experimenter Effects
Original: wiseman_schlitz_1997_experimenter_staring — Wiseman & Schlitz (1997), "Experimenter Effects and the Remote Detection of Staring"
⚠️ Summary Statistics
Mixed Results
Summary Statistics
Mixed Results
Summary Statistics
⚠️ Notes
Mixed Results
Notes
Mixed Results
Notes
- 📄 galak_2012_correcting and
galak_2012_correcting_past_metaappear to be the same publication split into two catalog entries (experimental component and meta-analytic component). Both now have explicit Replicates links.